Used-Car Story
Names are fictitious to add to the SPOOKINESS
A nice lady bought a car, a nearly new 10k miles, CPO (Certified Pre-Owned) 2025 “Yugo” (remember, fictitious names and brands ;), and paid for an extended warranty.
She loves the car, and things were great until, the same week of the purchase, she tried to adjust the passenger side mirror and it wasn’t working correctly.
So, she dropped it off for repair at the dealer. But after she waited a week, they said the repair was declined by the manufacturer AND extended warranties because the car had been in a wreck and repaired. That was a big surprise!
A little digging online she found photos of the car with significant collision damage, on an insurance auction site; it had been hit in the passenger front corner, and the front door had a large hole in it. All of this damage had been repaired prior to purchase, but there was no damage disclosure.
She tried again to get the dealer to take care of things and at one point they even said they couldn’t be sure that she wasn’t the one who wrecked/damaged the car in the short time she’d owned it.
She also began to notice that the car was darting left and right every time it went over big bumps like the transitions on interstate bridges, yes at interstate speeds.
That’s when she looked for a second opinion and called us.
We agreed to at least look things over to help and do the alignment if needed. We easily confirmed the car darts left or right when going over big bumps (that’s why that’s called “bump steer”,) it also had significant torque steer, darting one direction on acceleration and the other direction when braking. Likely the same root cause; basically, any time the front suspension rose or dropped the steering would change to steer the car slightly left or right.
On inspection our team found no suspension/steering damage, nothing bent, nothing cracked/broken, we measured alignment angles, found them off, possible cause of darting, made the adjustments and then test drove it.
Well, slight improvement, but clearly not the fix, still significant bump steer. So, we re-inspected it and then we discovered the root cause: the right front steering knuckle was different than the left. The collision repair must have included replacing this knuckle with a used part, an incorrect part.
The steering knuckles are the primary suspension/steering part that connects everything: control arm ball joint, strut assy, tie rod end, wheel bearing, braking system, and ABS wheel speed sensor. The problem, that it was different, is unusual given how many things connect to it. How could it be installed, everything connect, fit, and work when it’s the wrong part?
Well, it’s because the replacement steering knuckle installed during the collision repair was one for a FWD front wheel drive model, but her car is the AWD All-Wheel Drive model! The only difference was the designed placement of the tie rod end attachment on the knuckle. On the FWD knuckle, it’s approx. 2.5” above the location for an AWD model.
This explains the bump steer. It’s geometry; the tie rods should be level/parallel to the horizon, and on the left side, it is level. The problem was that the right-side tie-rod end was angled up to the knuckle because of its placement 2.5” higher. So, this is actually an “easy” fix, replace the right side knuckle with the correct one.
The next observations we made were about the rest of the collision repair body work on the right front corner. an incorrect part.
There were dozens of shoddy repair workmanship errors, visible externally, with more trouble to be discovered once a technician would dig into the repair.
Finally, the mirror issue is either a mirror fault or damaged wiring inside the door. We were confident that without a thorough re-do on all aspects of the previous collision repair she would see a lot more trouble in the coming months and years of ownership.
She had already gotten some unfair push-back from the dealership denying responsibility for the condition of the car and even suggesting the damage could have happened under her ownership. So what could we do for her?
After completing our assessment, we presented her with a clearly written detailed description, with photos, of everything we saw and knew about what was causing her symptoms. We also counseled her on how to approach the dealership to demand a fair resolution to a very bad situation.
With our suggestions and reports she was able to connect with the managers at the dealership, and they agreed to take back the troubled car and exchange it for a cleaner car with no damage history!
This was a great final outcome to a very spooky car buying experience. I
n our experience, something like this usually happens from secondary car dealerships, not mainline dealers and especially not certified pre-owned cars. As a CPO car, once the problems started to appear, the dealership really should have responded in a more professional manner. But that’s one of the reasons
we’re here, trusted expert auto repair.
We can tackle pretty spooky situations, and, turn a nightmare into a friendly ghost story with a happy ending.










